Being John Malkovich

viewed November 14, 1999 at Century Plaza 10

For full information about this film, click here

This would be a movie that would inspire hours of contemplation if the experience of recollecting it weren't so darn pleasurable.  It raises questions of sexuality, celebrity, mass media consciousness and immortality, but in such an offhand, unassuming way that the overabundance of discussion topics give way to a happy, bewildered feeling of awe, as if someone has entered a portal into your mind and set it aglow.  You just enjoy this movie for what it presents to you, so generously.

The wonderful script by Charlie Kaufman (whose previous claim to fame was writing for "The Dana Carvey Show" -- who would have figured?),  mixes criticism and pop so seamlessly that the experience is unlike anything I've seen -- it's the devastating feeling of being thoughtfully provoked and thoroughly entertained all at once.  Scenes are loaded with both social meaning and wacky fun: out of a ten-gallon hat stuffed with brilliant scenes from this movie, I randomly pull out the one where Craig (John Cusack), the self-pitying starving artist, performs his beautifully crafted and perversely conceived puppet version of "Abelard and Heloise" with the forlorn correspondents carved in wood dry-humping before the audience of one little girl and her enraged father.  Right there we've got a double-edged look at the plight of performance artists, their lack of recognition by the public commingled with an unhealthy preoccupation with their tragic selves, with some arcane literary theological history thrown in the mix.  

This movie runs the gamut of culture from high to low, corporate to celebrity, metaphysical to zoological.  Director Spike Jonze (who must have contributed to the brilliance of :"Three Kings" in a role greater than his acting) unloads his fertile vision on us, and we sit back in awe.  We have company orientation videos with fabricated histories of pirates and midgets, traumatic chimpanzee flashbacks, 50-foot puppet-shows, a woman having sex with another woman through a man's body, and John Malkovich entering the mind of John Malkovich.  Even the running gags -- the endlessly witty plays on the word "Malkovich" and the shots of people being spit through the sky onto the New Jersey Turnpike -- elicited laughs from the rapt audience around me.

In many ways, this movie dares you to break it down to its implicative components, by satirizing those with an analytical disposition.  After Craig leaves Malkovich's mind, he can't help spewing out all sorts of theories about the meaning of him occupying another's consciousness that he's giddy with perplexity, a sputtering profundity at his love-object, the irresistibly power-driven Maxine (Catherine Keener).  All she cares about is whether she can charge admission to this portal into Malkovich.  As representatives of the movie's mindset, Maxine's focus on material results domineers over Craig's cerebral ponderings.  Everything else in the movie follows this dynamic, and illustrates that abundant invention and superb execution will make audiences credit you with profound meaning to boot.

So much of this movie's superb execution rests on its acting, and it's impossible to pick which is the best of the four main performances.  Cusack is both nuanced and exaggerated as the self-pitying puppeteer -- from his geeky speech patterns and his nihilistic leer, you can see his soul slouching inside his mortal shell.  Catherine Keener is his opposite and sole existential (or just plain sexual) tormentor, a woman so deprecatingly confident that her smile has "castrate you" written all over it.  The fact that she is exponentially sexier than Cameron Diaz in this movie is not a letdown at all -- what we miss in Diaz' frizzled hair and scrappy outfits we retrieve in a wonderfully balanced, quirky and funny performance.  Recalling Geena Davis in her pre-jock days, Diaz with her off-kilter voice and flailing limbs is today's reigning screwball comedienne.  The way she embraces her newfound lesbian/transsexual identity is, to say the least, inspiring.

Of course this movie wouldn't work without John Malkovich, but his performance ensures that his presence is more than just a gimmick.  He works hard for his title credit, half the time playing himself possessed by others, the other half presenting a self that, authentic or not, feels genuine, human and very... John Malkovich.  

Each of these characters is seeking some kind of powerful or special figure who enthralls them; each of them except John Malkovich, who seems oddly, disarmingly mundane, and whose only desire is to be left alone and have a happy, humdrum life.  His personality is really as banal as anyone's (a cab driver vaguely recognizes him; he's ordering monogrammed towels and poking at chinese takeout).  These scenes however do take on a thrilling quality when seen through malkovich's eyes, capturing the visual and spiritual essence of what cinema is all about.  The heightened state of seeing through another's eyes is further heightened by the allure of celebrity; of not just seeing things, but seeing them as somebody.  But such identities get turned on their ear when one realizes that Malkovich is stylizing his presence as himself, playing both with and against his enigmatic public persona.  Then there's Charlie Sheen, who is unforgettable as he spoofs his own scandalized, tabloid self.  One wonders if another Charlie Sheen exists.

Like a lot of recent concept driven films (The Truman Show, The Sixth Sense)., Being John Malkovich invites a lot of probing into how the movie's imagined world works.  But this movie enraptures you in ways the others could only dream of.  With a relentless invention triangulated by cultural literacy, humor, and great acting, this movie spins the mind into a world of unforeseen delights.

This movie inspired another online review search, with the results as follows, in order of quality:

Village Voice (short but packed with references, like the movie itself)

Roger Ebert

San Francisco Examiner

Boston Phoenix

Home